Book Review – Why I am Catholic (and You Should Be Too) by Brandon Vogt

One of the greatest commonalities I find among families is that all of us have at least one person who has left the Catholic faith. For those of us with teen or adult children who have left it is often very painful and confusing. Especially when it is one child that has left, while the others in the family have stayed. Sometimes it is a brother or parent who has left. Other times we have friends who we love dearly but have no faith in God or are of the “spiritual but not religious category” so many claim today. We want to reach these people but we don’t know what to say.
Enter Brandon Vogt’s new book, “Why I am Catholic (and You Should Be Too)” from Ave Maria Press. You may be familiar with Brandon Vogt from various videos he’s made, past books or know that he works for Bishop Robert Barron. This is the first book of his I’ve read and I enjoyed it very much. First, he is honest and open about his own conversion to Catholicism. Secondly, it’s tone is conversational; not heavy handed as he lays out our faith. He doesn’t skirt around the tough topics people are at odds with the Church about. And he lets readers know where to find more information about those topics since he can’t cover them all fully himself. Lastly, he doesn’t rely solely on his feelings and opinions but quotes the great thinkers of our faith in a way that is accessible.
I highlighted many passages, but I think this is my favorite “Maybe in a strange and confused world, the Catholic Church looks so backward because everyone else is facing the wrong direction.” Because really, deep in my soul, there are many times when I want to say to many people, “it’s not us, it’s you that is wrong about marriage, birth control, the death penalty, abortion, women priests, and on and on.” I don’t go around saying that because it’s not the right way, but Brandon’s book, politely and firmly, using truth, beauty, goodness and facts points out why you should be Catholic too.
Remember, this book is not meant for a Catholic firmly planted in the Church, so don’t read it that way. You will learn from this book though and you can use what you learn to draw others to the faith. I will be buying a few copies to give to people who are questioning, who wonder if the Church is for them, who have wandered off. I can also use some of Brandon’s examples when I talk to people. I encourage you to read this book and help yourself in your evangelization efforts!

Copies are avaible on Amazon.

Deanna Bartalini, ©2017

Deanna Bartalini

Deanna Bartalini

Deanna Bartalini is a Catholic wife, mom, writer and educator. With a Masters in Educational Leadership, another in Pastoral Administration and a Bachelors in Elementary Education and Linguistics; it seems she is always teaching someone about something especially about faith, Catholicism and how it all fits into our daily lives. Deanna is available to lead retreats and speak at catechist and ministry events. Learn more about her on her website,;;; on Twitter @notlukewarm316, Goodreads, and Pinterest.

Leave a Reply

next post: The Truth about Sexuality

previous post: Lessons From the Craft Faire